Ah, Toby. He’s one of the most mysterious guys on Pretty Little Liars, you definitely have to give him that! He’s been accused of murder, of being A, and of just plain being up to no good. He’s been on the wrong side of the law and he WAS the law. He did a brief stint as a Rosewood PD rookie, but turned in his badge a few episodes into the 6th season. Like all the characters in Pretty Little Liars, Toby has a few enemies. Let’s check them out!
Related: The Boys of Rosewood
Toby’s Biggest Enemies on Pretty Little Liars
Garrett was a former police officer for the Rosewood Police Department. He was initially assigned to investigate the murder case of Alison. Circumstances led to Garrett being charged with not only Alison’s murder but Maya’s as well. He was eventually being cleared of both charges. He knew many secrets that he was going to tell Spencer, Toby’s girlfriend, but was murdered by A before he could do so. Garrett was also part of a high school club known as the N.A.T. Club, which means We See All in Latin. The group consisted of Jason, Ian and Garrett and they would all film teenage girls in town through their bedroom windows. Each member of the group had some type of connection to Spencer. Jason is her half-brother, Ian is her brother-in-law and they dated and Garrett had romantic feelings for her. All of the members also had a connection with Spencer’s sister, Melissa as well. Jason once kissed Melissa, Ian dated then later married Melissa and Garrett dated Melissa prior to his arrest.
Toby and Alison were friends at one time and almost kissed once too. However, their friendship turned sour and they became bitter enemies. Alison blackmailed Toby into taking the heat for an incident involving Jenna or she would tell everyone about their relationship. Toby was sent to a juvenile detention center after his confession. Alison and Toby were at his house once when his mother woke up at 4:00 in the afternoon. Alison told Toby his mom was lazy, he said she was rude and told her to leave and she told Toby he was a loser. Later, Toby was a suspect in Alison’s death, but was eventually cleared of the charges.
Related: The Girls of Rosewood
Jenna forced Toby into having a sexual relationship with her but when he insisted that the relationship end, Jenna was not happy. She threatened him by saying she would tell the whole town that he is the one who forced himself on her.
In season 4, Alison is confirmed to be Red Coat but says that A is also after her and she wears the red coat as a disguise. In the next season, it shows Red Coat appearing to Emily for a second time. The first time, Alison had CeCe disguise as Red Coat so that A would be distracted enough so Alison could turn the saw off and save Emily. This time, Emily is in her car, planning to meet up with Toby. Emily sees Red Coat go into the place Toby works, which scares off Red Coat. It is thought that Red Coat lured Emily to the meeting by using Toby’s phone.
As far as enemies go on Pretty Little Liars, Toby actually has it pretty good. Technically, you could say that A is also his enemy, because he/she/it is also his girlfriend’s biggest enemy, but aside from a minor attempt on his life here and there, A really doesn’t seem to focus much on Toby. He can also be his own worst enemy when it comes to his relationship with Spencer. He expects complete honesty, but gets a bit judgy when it’s given.